What if she wasn't trying to be picked?

November 13, 2026•3 min read

Hey Girl Hey!

I have been turning over this question in my head: what if some of the behaviors we call "pick me" were never actually about being picked?

Because I keep seeing the same words show up when women talk about doing too much: codependent. Overfunctioning. Overresponsible. And listen, sometimes those words are accurate. Sometimes we are absolutely out here completing grown people's group projects when they did not ask for help and have no intention of contributing. Fair.

But that is not the whole story.

I realized that when another capable adult makes a destructive decision that does not directly harm me, I can offer my perspective and let their decision remain their business. I do not need to rescue every adult from the consequences of being grown.

My shit gets activated somewhere else: adversity, chaos, unfairness and situations where somebody has to become functional because the environment is not.

In those moments, overfunctioning may not begin as a personality trait or a desperate attempt to be needed. Sometimes it begins because you are trying to survive. Sometimes you become the reliable one because unreliability has consequences. You become the one who anticipates, plans, fixes, explains and carries because dropping the ball does not just mean an inconvenience. It means the whole damn thing may fall apart.

And after a while, that survival role starts looking like your identity.

From the outside, you can present as the woman who needs to be the good one, the capable one, the one who never causes problems, the one who proves her value by doing more. It can look like you are auditioning to be chosen when you may have been trying to be fair, useful, safe—or simply a good person in circumstances that kept rewarding you for carrying what other people dropped.

Girl, that distinction matters.

Because if we misdiagnose the origin, we will prescribe the wrong healing. You cannot shame yourself out of a strategy that once kept you safe. First, you have to acknowledge what it did for you. Then you can decide whether it still belongs in the life you are building now.

And I Got Questions.

Was I trying to be chosen, or was I trying to make the situation survivable?

Did I freely choose this responsibility, or did chaos assign it to me because I was the person most capable of handling it?

And now that the emergency is over, do I still need to be her?

That is the part I want you to steal: before you label a behavior, ask what job it was performing. Then ask whether that job is still open.

Since We're Friends Now… Things I'd Send the Group Chat

Today's recommendation is not a product. It is a pause: do not diagnose your whole character from one behavior without asking what conditions taught you to behave that way. Context does not remove responsibility, but it can replace shame with understanding—and understanding gives you somewhere useful to go next.

This is one of the layers I am exploring in Pick Me Girl, because sometimes you end up presenting as a pick-me without ever intending to audition for a damn thing.

Tell me: what role did chaos assign you that you are finally ready to resign from?

Love,
Ash

Written somewhere between therapy appointments, geriatric jogs and Outlook notifications — from the iPad of a currently overstimulated millennial woman who loves God, good questions and a practical next step.

Back to Blog